Philosophers routinely invoke solidarity as a requirement of liberatory politics, yet they remain divided over its nature. Dominant accounts treat solidarity as reciprocal interpersonal care grounded in shared interests or a common identity. However, these accounts are both descriptively inadequate and normatively dangerous: they make solidarity indistinguishable from community belonging and, more troublingly, elevate homogeneity as a precondition for collective resistance. Drawing on cases of coalition politics, Solidarity for the Long Haul: Beyond Identity, Beyond Reciprocity, develops a novel conception of solidarity as political intimacy: a bond of resistant interdependence between agents.
While impersonal structures of authority weigh on our ability to deliberate productively and realize our intentions, solidarity is a distinctive political form of intimacy that confers the relational agency needed to combat oppression and its structural harms. Rather than positing that solidarity arises from recognized group membership and requires reciprocal actions for collective benefit, I argue that agents in solidarity act against their institutional positioning to create new social groups and become fellows. Workers withhold their labor to collectively determine the scope of their duties; political subjects unite across differences to define themselves beyond their social group membership. Solidarity’s intimate relationships not only illuminate the political, legal, and economic structures of authority that constrain our interests and identities but also show them to be needless. In doing so, solidarity provides agents freedom to constitute themselves anew.
Constructed from and tested against my personal labor organizing practices, my dissertation’s theory of solidarity as political intimacy captures solidarity’s real-world cases more accurately than prevailing accounts. By focusing on agents’ relationship to authority, solidarity as political intimacy distinguishes solidarity’s paradigmatic civic-minded motives (i.e., we-thinking) from altruism. It explains, for instance, why the US student encampments for Gaza are genuine cases of solidarity, whereas the practice of allyship is not, even though both involve agents acting as "outsiders." Further, by avoiding the exclusionary requirement of a shared identity (or identifiable features) prevalent in dominant accounts, solidarity as political intimacy offers a more robust grounding for collective ethics; it empowers agents and collectives by uniting across differences, prioritizing heterogeneity, and thus serving as an inclusive ideal.